1830 Birth:407 Birth year of 1830 estimated based on age (20 years) in 1850 census enumeration; birth place of Ohio taken from same source.

1850 U.S. Census:407 Sarah enumerated in the household of her husband Jesiah Baughman in Union Township, Auglaize County, Ohio as a female, age 20, born in Ohio. Children enumerated were Minerva, age 3, and Catherine, age 10 months.

1860 U.S. Census:408 Sarah enumerated in the household of her husband Jesiah Baughman in Mifflin Township, Auglaize County, Ohio as a female, age 30, born in Ohio. Children enumerated were Minerva, age 12; Catherine, age 10; Isenvory (?), age 7; Missouri, a female age 4; and Kansas, a male age 2.

1870 U.S. Census:2678 Sarah enumerated in the household of her husband Jesiah Baughman in Clay Township, Auglaize County, Ohio as a female, age 33 (!), female, white, keeping house, born in Ohio. Children enumerated were Geneva (?), age 16; Missouri, a female age 14; Kansas, a male age 12; Mary, age 10; Sarah, age 7; and John, age 1.

1880 U.S. Census:2679 Sarah enumerated in the household of her husband Jesse Baughman in Marion Township, Franklin County, Ohio as a white female, age 29, daughter, single, at home, born in Ohio, father born in Ohio, mother born in Ohio. Children enumerated were Catherine, age 29; Kansas a male age 21; Sarah, age 17; and Eva, age 11.